• About
    • About
    • Presentation Dates
    • Publications
  • Seminar Topics
  • Resources
    • Gifted Websites Links
    • Exceptional Books for you and your children
    • Publications by Tara Lenga >
      • IAGC 2012: To Stress or not to Stress, That is the Question
      • IAGC 2011: Navigating in a Social World
      • IAGC 2010: Emergence of the Gifted Child
  • Testimonials
  • Contact
  • Blog: Curiosity Corner
  Exceptional Kids:
Gifted and other Exceptionalities

Don't knock what you don't know:

12/2/2012

0 Comments

 
Articles like "Against Accelerating the Gifted Child" posted in the New York Times (October 14th, 2012) frustrate me.  And although I usually don't write opinions on what I post (link included below) I felt compelled to reply to this one. The child in question is Tanishq, a 9 year old college student. The author to this article seems to be against accelerating a gifted child.
 
Does the author understand that Tanishq is of a level of giftedness that is like 2 in a million (according to Dr. Deborah Ruf in her book 5 Levels of Giftedness)? That Tanishq would not be an ideal example of acceleration for the more “typical” gifted child – if there even is such a thing?
 
The author also likes to point to a powerful document entitled
“A Nation Deceived”. That the data for research was gathered subjectively from gifted students themselves. Where else is this data supposed to come from? If you are researching the effects of abuse would you not talk to the victims?
 
The author is found saying that Maureen Neihart, and author for a report in the Gifted Child Quarterly warns that acceleration “may be harmful to unselected students who are arbitrarily accelerated on the basis of I.Q., achievement, or social maturity,”. Sure but what this author fails to mention is there is a great tool frequently used to ensure that all areas of a child’s live/world is considered before making an acceration decision “The IOWA Acceleration scale”. This tool was created for that very purpose of making sure that the decision was made looking at the whole
child and all of their needs. Anything is harmful if you don’t weight the pro’s and con’s seriously.
 
This author also mentions that “many of these students opt to repeat an eighth-grade year in order to gain maturity”. Well I’d like to meet one of those students of today’s world. She ends er article with wanting to give students “the gift of time. Time to develop, time to grow up, time to feel secure in themselves and their achievements.” Wonderful. Let’s do that. But why does it need to be wasted time. How are they going to feel secure in themselves if they are not allowed to achieve at the level they are capable. What message of self-confidence are we giving them? 

How about we give them the gift of for our accelerated students on the other end? Time between high school and college to travel. Time to explore their passions. Time to put their own unique mark on the world. That is truly a gift of time.
Picture

Against Accelerating
the Gifted Child.

0 Comments
    Picture

    Author

    Tara Lenga is the mom of two exceptional kids. 

    As a strategy consultant for 20 years, she has been creatively working with families by creating and implementing customized coping strategies for children spanning the spectrum of learning.

    Tara Lenga holds a B.A. 
    in child development and psychology and a
    post-graduate degree
    in Art Therapy.

    Picture

    Archives

    December 2012

    Categories

    All
    Acceleration
    Achievement
    Advocacy
    Association
    Books
    Change
    Children
    Courage
    Development
    Emotion
    Emotional
    Excitable
    Gifted
    Growth
    Iagc
    Illinois
    Iq
    Level
    Media
    Nation Deceived
    Over Load
    Perfect
    Progress
    Read
    Reality
    Risk
    Routine
    Shift
    Skipping
    Social
    Structure
    Succeed
    Thinker
    Time
    Toys

    RSS Feed












































































































































































































































































Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • About
    • About
    • Presentation Dates
    • Publications
  • Seminar Topics
  • Resources
    • Gifted Websites Links
    • Exceptional Books for you and your children
    • Publications by Tara Lenga >
      • IAGC 2012: To Stress or not to Stress, That is the Question
      • IAGC 2011: Navigating in a Social World
      • IAGC 2010: Emergence of the Gifted Child
  • Testimonials
  • Contact
  • Blog: Curiosity Corner